REPORTING PATERNITY
STATISTICS IN FORENSIC CASES
DNA
CASEWORK
GENERAL
SUPPORT IN FORENSIC CASES
CONVICTED
OFFENDER DATABANKING
COLLECTION
AND STORAGE OF FETAL TISSUE
Paternity
Testing Corporation is a full service forensic laboratory
for DNA casework and convicted offender databanking. Forensic
paternity testing is available as well as testing to match
body fluid or tissue specimens to a suspect or victim.
For databanking and certain other casework PTC uses the
PCR method of DNA testing, including the FBI's thirteen
core loci, amelogenin (for sex determination) and other
genetic systems. We will continue to keep RFLP testing
on line so that it is available for cases such as mixed
stains, or for attorneys who are more comfortable presenting
RFLP results in court. We also are offering Y chromosome
analysis and mitochondrial DNA analysis. PTC is accredited
by the American Association of Blood Banks and ISO 17025.
PTC offers the highest degree of care
and reliability in all of our laboratory work. We provide a high level of
service, both in working with you on case work and in providing expert
witnesses and attorney support. We have very competitive rates. We also provide
fast turn-around, so that you can keep high profile cases moving.
For paternity testing, PTC's
advantages are even more important in the investigation and prosecution of a
crime. Most laboratories guarantee only a 99.0% probability of paternity even
for forensic paternity. Such low numbers are much less suitable in the criminal
context, where evidence must show the suspect guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.
A 99.0% probability of paternity, indicating a genetic pattern found on average
in one in every one hundred people, and possibly much more common in the case
at hand, is obviously inappropriate in a context where prosecutors prefer to
see much higher numbers. A knowledgeable defense attorney is sure to argue that
the lower numbers leave more than reasonable doubt, and the jury may agree.
PTC's 99.99% minimum guarantee
assures law enforcement agencies that our laboratory will continue testing
until we have identified a genetic pattern that fits no more than one in ten
thousand individuals on average. In most cases we narrow it down to a pattern
that fits fewer than one in one hundred thousand individuals. These numbers
make it much easier to obtain a conviction.
PTC also prepares paternity reports
that are specific to the forensic context, at no additional charge.
Paternity
Testing Corporation primarily uses the PCR/STR type of DNA
analysis for paternity testing, but also has RFLP avaliable.
In some states, if one side objects to allowing a paternity
test in court, the samples can easily be retested in the
other DNA system.
REPORTING PATERNITY STATISTICS IN
FORENSIC CASES
There is much questioning within the
forensic community as to the best way to report paternity statistics in
forensic cases. There is no consistent practice at this time. Some laboratories
report the "probability of paternity" which the American Association
of Blood Banks requires for private paternity laboratories. Others use a
likelihood ratio. Some report a frequency number as in crime stain comparison
situations. Still others shun numbers and simply report whether the alleged
father was excluded or not excluded.
Paternity Testing Corporation will
prepare the report as requested. Our preference in forensic cases is to
calculate a "one in" number, indicating that this is a haploid DNA
pattern which you would expect to see in one in every __________ individuals.
We believe that this provides the most useful and convincing information to the
jury. Attorneys who specialize in prosecution of DNA cases have advised that
the jury is confused by probabilities and likelihood ratios. The frequency
number is a concept that the jury can understand. As a result, it is the most
effective statistic in the prosecution of a crime.
We are interested in your thoughts
and experience regarding this question. If you have an opinion about the best
statistics to use in a forensic paternity case, or have a revealing war story
to share, or if you have questions about paternity statistics, please send PTC
an email at
info@ptclabs.com.
DNA CASEWORK
PTC is available to provide fast and
reliable DNA testing for your cases. We provide PCR testing using the FBI's
thirteen core loci, and we have other PCR systems available. We also are able
to provide exceptionally high levels of discrimination using RFLP testing if
there is a sufficient quantity of DNA.
Our turn-around time for DNA casework
depends upon the quality of the samples. For samples such as blood, our
turn-around time is generally within ten days.
GENERAL SUPPORT IN FORENSIC CASES
PTC has expert witnesses available
for depositions and testimony. Our expert witnesses include our Laboratory
Director, who is an M.D., Ph.D., an Assistant Laboratory Director, who is a
Ph.D., and our Laboratory Supervisor, a former DNA criminalist for the St.
Louis Metropolitan Police Department.
We work with the client's attorneys
every step of the way in preparing the case. We are able to provide
"prove-up" questions and other assistance. Our scientific staff is
experienced in assisting prosecutors to present DNA evidence at trial. We have
an attorney on staff who is available to provide assistance to other attorneys
as needed.
CONVICTED OFFENDER DATABANKING
PTC is also available to test and
report the DNA profiles of convicted criminals for State law enforcement
agencies. PTC brings to convicted offender databanking the same expertise,
level of reliability in testing, and level of service that we provide in all of
our paternity and forensic testing.
PTC has high throughput capability
for databanking. We develop a profile of each sample using the FBI's thirteen
core loci. All results are returned in a CODIS format. The client laboratory
can perform quality control by a direct comparison of profiles processed by the
client laboratory, regardless of which platform (CE or FMBio) the client uses
for its own testing.
PTC makes convicted offender
databanking available to those agencies that would like to decrease their
backlog of offender samples. As in all of our testing, we offer the highest
degree of care and reliability in testing. In addition we provide a high level
of service and fast turn-around, at a reasonable price.
PROTOCOL FOR COLLECTION AND STORAGE OF
FETAL TISSUE
-
The physician should separate the fetal tissue from the mother’s tissue. This
step is very important. If the tissues are pulverized and mixed, it is nearly
impossible to obtain a fetal DNA profile.
-
Do NOT store tissue in formaldehyde. Tissue can be stored refrigerated, in
saline buffer or stored frozen with or without saline buffer.
-
Tissue can be placed in any leak proof container.
-
Tissue should be frozen immediately after collection (if freezing is not
possible then refrigerate). Tissue can be frozen either at –20C or –80C.
-
Tissue should be shipped overnight for next day delivery, and packed in freezer
packs or in dry ice adequate to keep the tissue cold for at least 72 hours.
Overnight shipments are occasionally misrouted and 72 hours will cover most
shipment errors.
Please ship specimens to: John Beckwith, Paternity Testing Corporation, 300
Portland St., Columbia, MO 65201, (573)442-9948
-
PTC should be notified that the shipment has been sent and a tracking number
should be provided to PTC. PTC will need tracking information in the event that
the shipment is not delivered as expected.
-
Either an EDTA blood tube or 4 buccal swabs should be provided from the victims
and suspects. Buccal swabs should be rubbed on the inside of the cheek (2 on
each side) for a minimum of 15 seconds each. If a mouth infection is present
then it will be necessary to obtain a blood specimen.
-
Blood should be stored refrigerated until shipped. Blood should be shipped
overnight and in hot weather blood should be shipped using cold packs.
-
Buccal swabs should be allowed to dry in the evidence envelope for a few hours,
and then frozen until shipped. Buccal swabs should be shipped overnight, but it
is not necessary to keep buccal swabs cold during shipping.
-
If you have questions about specimen collection or shipping instructions,
please call our toll free number (888) 837-8323
|